Relaxed Zoning Could Create Millions of New Homes in America's Single-Family Neighborhoods

Adding a backyard cottage or mother-in-law unit to even a small fraction of single family lots would broaden the mix of available homes and ease the affordability crisis

- Creating an additional home on 1 in 10 single-family lots would yield nearly 3.3 million new homes in the 17 metro areas analyzed

- The extent of new housing created this way could meaningfully slow price growth over the long term, even in the most expensive coastal metros

News provided by

Zillow

Dec 18, 2019, 08:00 ET

SEATTLE, Dec. 18, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- Allowing for even modest amounts of new density in the nation's overwhelmingly single-family neighborhoods could lead to millions of new homes nationwide, according to a Zillow® analysis, helping alleviate a housing affordability crisis that has been decades in the making.

If the Los Angeles area, for example, continues to add housing largely as it has over the past two decades it could grow its housing stock by an estimated 14.5% over the next two decades. But if 1 in 10 single-family lots were redeveloped or otherwise allowed to accommodate a second home, the area's housing stock could grow by 21% over the same period – or nearly 387,000 additional homes.

Building at the status quo over the next two decades is expected to produce about 10 million new homes across the 17 large metros analyzed nationwide, a more than 20% boost over the almost 50 million homes these markets currently have. Allowing for two units on just 10% of single-family lots would add an additional 3.3 million homes on top of that 10 million, a boost of almost 27% over current levels.

Single-family neighborhoods account for the lion's share of land in metropolitan America, and over the years have generally become insulated from denser redevelopment by a thickening tangle of regulations, reflecting entrenched local interests that benefit from keeping a neighborhood as it is. In America's expensive coastal cities especiallyⁱ, natural barriers and environmental concerns have exacerbated that trend, limiting most new housing to islands of density – often near transit or in formerly non-residential areas – in an otherwise stagnant sea of no-growth.

That shortage of new housing development coupled with sustained demand for it, especially in those pricey, coastal cities, has contributed mightily to an affordability squeeze. Over the past 20 years, the median home value in the Los Angeles metro area has more than doubled, in the San Francisco Bay Area it has nearly doubled, and in Seattle it has grown by almost two-thirds. In contrast, metros in the South where it has historically been much easier to build new homes, especially on the periphery, have seen home prices grow a little more than 10% in that time.

Looking inward at already-developed single-family tracts and allowing for two, three or even four homes where just one stands today could reignite housing development without contributing to sprawl, the analysis shows. Indeed, Minneapolis and Oregon already have allowed for significantly more density in historically single-family neighborhoods, and other places like Los Angeles and Seattle have taken more modest steps to allow additional accessory dwelling units. This strategy also likely would expand the range of home types available, whereas the status quo produces mostly single-family homes and units in very large apartment buildings.

There are fears that intense densification may risk diminishing the character of neighborhoods – more concrete where there had been greenery, competition for street parking, etc. But in practice, allowing just 1 in 10 single-family homes in a given neighborhood to host a livable in-law suite above the garage, a bachelor apartment in the basement or a cottage in the back yard isn't likely to drastically alter an existing streetscape. Redeveloping more single-family lots and/or allowing them to host a triplex/quadplex or a row of four townhomes may result in more noticeable change, but also more significantly tackle the housing shortage and affordability crisis.

In the Los Angeles area, allowing four homes on 20% of single-family lots could yield a housing stock increase of more than 2.3 million homes, or a 53.4% boost over the current stock when combined with homes already expected to be built. This more extreme measure would add more than 1.5 million more homes than allowing only one additional home on the same lots.

"The challenge of solving big metros' housing affordability crisis is the scale of what's needed. If it was just a few more affordable apartment buildings it wouldn't be a problem, but we need a lot of additional supply to put the pace of long term price and rent growth in line with income and wage growth," said Skylar Olsen, Zillow's director of economic research. "Asking a few neighborhoods to absorb that change on their own is asking for a community to accept a totally different neighborhood in the future – a neighborhood different from the one they bought into and grew to love. So the questions become, if we could share the influx of new housing across the full metro, could we add enough and would anyone really notice?"

Metropolitan Area	Existing Homes	Estimated new homes built by 2040 under status quo	Additional homes built if 1 in 10 single-family lots added a second unit	Additional homes built if 1 in 50 single-family lots added a second unit
New York-Newark, NY-NJ-CT-PA CSA	8,678,243	1,000,113	419,094	83,819
Los Angeles-Long Beach, CA CSA	5,966,775	863,088	386,805	77,361
Chicago-Naperville, IL-IN-WI CSA	3,744,840	562,952	237,295	47,459
Washington-Baltimore-Arlington, DC-MD-VA-WV-PA CSA	3,649,276	1,045,717	259,940	51,988
San Jose-San Francisco-Oakland, CA CSA	3,081,284	364,175	204,097	40,819
Boston-Worcester-Providence, MA-RI-NH-CT CSA	3,179,941	368,362	189,581	37,916
Philadelphia-Reading-Camden, PA-NJ-DE-MD CSA	2,710,583	369,816	208,473	41,695
Dallas-Fort Worth, TX-OK CSA	2,779,502	915,215	200,152	40,030
Houston-The Woodlands, TX CSA	2,451,928	754,980	175,859	35,172
Atlanta--Athens-Clarke County--Sandy Springs, GA CSA	2,392,320	1,119,322	183,599	36,720
Detroit-Warren-Ann Arbor, MI CSA	2,090,434	294,224	167,298	33,460
Seattle-Tacoma, WA CSA	1,825,299	468,351	126,359	25,272
Phoenix-Mesa-Scottsdale, AZ Metro Area	1,694,010	736,634	130,801	26,160
Minneapolis-St. Paul, MN-WI CSA	1,549,537	380,893	115,245	23,049
Cleveland-Akron-Canton, OH CSA	1,449,647	198,511	111,058	22,212
San Diego-Carlsbad, CA Metro Area	1,123,006	229,044	71,820	14,364
Denver-Aurora, CO CSA	1,365,902	392,501	96,754	19,351

About Zillow
Zillow® is transforming how people buy, sell, rent and finance homes by creating seamless real estate transactions for today's on-demand consumer. Zillow is the leading real estate and rental marketplace and a trusted source for data, inspiration and knowledge among both consumers and real estate professionals.

Zillow's proprietary data, technology and industry partnerships put Zillow at nearly every major point of the home shopping experience, helping consumers search for and get into their new home faster. Zillow now offers a fully integrated home shopping experience that includes access to for sale and rental listings, Zillow Offers^®, which provides a new, hassle-free way to buy and sell eligible homes directly through Zillow; and Zillow Home Loans, Zillow's affiliated lender that provides an easy way to receive mortgage pre-approvals and financing. Zillow Premier Agent instantly connects buyers and sellers with its network of real estate professionals to help guide them through the home shopping process. For renters, Zillow's innovations are streamlining the way people search, tour, apply and pay rent for leased properties.

In addition to Zillow.com, Zillow operates the most popular suite of mobile real estate apps, with more than two dozen apps across all major platforms. Launched in 2006, Zillow is owned and operated by Zillow Group, Inc. (NASDAQ: Z and ZG) and headquartered in Seattle.

Zillow and Zillow Offers are registered trademarks of Zillow, Inc.

ⁱ The expensive coastal cities' current housing affordability crisis has been decades in the making, the result of slowing metropolitan growth in the face of sustained housing demand. This research explores how much new housing could be added in a handful of large markets if current density restrictions in single-family zoned areas were relaxed. For a deeper dive into the historic building trends that have contributed to this crunch we encourage you to read our research here.

SOURCE Zillow